A Matter for the Jury

A Matter for the Jury

Peter Murphy

The Second Ben Schroeder Novel

It is 1964 and Ben Schroeder, first introduced in A Higher Duty, is building his career at the Bar; juggling the demands of different challenging cases, while trying to allow a little romance into his life.

Ben is already defending a vicar, accused of indecent assault on a choir boy, when he is plunged into a capital murder case.

The accused is Billy Cottage, charged with murder after a frenzied attack on a young courting couple aboard a houseboat.

The young man, Frank Gilliam, dies in the attack, while his girlfriend, Jennifer Doyce, is raped and seriously injured.

The attacker steals a gold cross and chain from Jennifer, which makes the crime a capital offence.

When the police recover the cross and chain from Billy’s sister, and find his fingerprint inside the houseboat, things start to look ominous. But then comes the crucial piece of evidence of his propensity to sing a particular song.

In his fight to save Billy Cottage’s life, Ben finds that he has both the law and the facts against him; and the tide of public opinion has not yet turned against capital punishment.

‘Utterly compelling’ David Ambrose

‘A gripping courtroom drama’ Paul Magrath, ICLR

  • Sequel to the highly successful A Higher Duty introducing lead character, Ben Schroeder
  • This novel recreates the drama and tension of a capital murder trial in England before abolition in 1965
  • Interest in workings of British justice system increasing thanks to popularity of books such as The Secret Barrister which has earned £1.1M since publication and was the second highest selling autobiography in 2018, behind Michelle Obama
  • For fans of BBC drama series Silk, Judge John Deed, Law And Order and other courtroom thrillers
  • Peter Murphy’s extensive legal experience adds authenticity to his writing

Paperback

RRP: £12.99

ISBN: 9781843442851

Published: July 23, 2014

Extent: 416 pages

Ebook

RRP: £4.99

ISBN: 9781843442875

Published: July 24, 2014

Reviews

In A Higher Duty Peter Murphy wrote more about the barristers themselves. Here the spotlight is on the defendants, the witnesses, the judges, and even the hangman since this is 1964 and capital murder means what it says

David Wurtzel , Counsel Magazine

‘A Matter for the Jury is a page-turner’

Historical Novel Society

‘gripping courtroom drama’

Barrister , ICLR

‘An utterly compelling and harrowing tale of life and death’

novelist

‘One of the subplots … delivers a huge and unexpected twist towards the end of the novel, for which I was totally unprepared’

Helen Walters , Fiction Is Stranger Than Fact

Frequently Asked Questions

What is "A Matter for the Jury" about?

The Second Ben Schroeder Novel

It is 1964 and Ben Schroeder, first introduced in A Higher Duty, is building his career at the Bar; juggling the demands of different challenging cases, while trying to allow a little romance into his life.

Ben is already defending a vicar, accused of indecent assault on a choir boy, when he is plunged into a capital murder case.

The accused is Billy Cottage, charged with murder after a frenzied attack on a young courting couple aboard a houseboat.

The young man, Frank Gilliam, dies in the attack, while his girlfriend, Jennifer Doyce, is raped and seriously injured.

The attacker steals a gold cross and chain from Jennifer, which makes the crime a capital offence.

When the police recover the cross and chain from Billy's sister, and find his fingerprint inside the houseboat, things start to look ominous. But then comes the crucial piece of evidence of his propensity to sing a particular song.

In his fight to save Billy Cottage's life, Ben finds that he has both the law and the facts against him; and the tide of public opinion has not yet turned against capital punishment.

'Utterly compelling' David Ambrose

'A gripping courtroom drama' Paul Magrath, ICLR

  • Sequel to the highly successful A Higher Duty introducing lead character, Ben Schroeder
  • This novel recreates the drama and tension of a capital murder trial in England before abolition in 1965
  • Interest in workings of British justice system increasing thanks to popularity of books such as The Secret Barrister which has earned £1.1M since publication and was the second highest selling autobiography in 2018, behind Michelle Obama
  • For fans of BBC drama series Silk, Judge John Deed, Law And Order and other courtroom thrillers
  • Peter Murphy's extensive legal experience adds authenticity to his writing
Who wrote "A Matter for the Jury"?

"A Matter for the Jury" was written by Peter Murphy.

Born in 1946, Peter Murphy graduated from Cambridge University and pursued a career in the law in England, the United States and The Hague. He practised as a barrister in London for a decade, then took up a professorship at a law school in Texas, a position he held for more than twenty years. Towards the end of that period he returned to Europe as counsel at the Yugoslavian War Crimes Tribunal in The Hague for almost a decade. In 2007 he returned to England to take up an appointment as a judge of the Crown Court. He retired as Resident Judge and Honorary Recorder of Peterborough in 2015.

Peter started writing fiction more than twenty years ago, but following his retirement from the bench he became a full-time author, often drawing on the many experiences of his former career. Two political thrillers about the American presidency: Removal and Test of Resolve were followed by eight legal thrillers in the Ben Schroeder series about a barrister practising in London in the 1960s and 1970s. Alongside those he also penned the light-hearted series of short story collections featuring Judge Walden of Bermondsey in the ‘Rumpole' tradition, based in part on his own experiences as a lawyer and judge, and recently published A Statue for Jacob, based on the true story of Jacob de Haven.

Peter passed away in July 2022.

Who would enjoy "A Matter for the Jury"?
"A Matter for the Jury" is perfect for readers who enjoy books about crime & mystery and political / legal thriller.
Is "A Matter for the Jury" part of a series?

Yes, "A Matter for the Jury" is part of the "A Ben Schroeder Legal Thriller" series. It's book 2 in the series.

Peter Murphy

Peter Murphy

Born in 1946, Peter Murphy graduated from Cambridge University and pursued a career in the law in England, the United States and The Hague. He practised as a barrister in London for a decade, then took up a professorship at a law school in Texas, a position he held for more than twenty years. Towards the end of that period he returned to Europe as counsel at the Yugoslavian War Crimes Tribunal in The Hague for almost a decade. In 2007 he returned to England to take up an appointment as a judge of the Crown Court. He retired as …

Author Profile Page